I understand where GCPL is coming from... but that is because, well... I agree with the idea.
In BN (which i know, isnt chao) Players who have earned a name for themselves, get to stay in the clan long after they become inactive. However, players who log on every couple of days, but after a month, no one knows them... they get kicked. Why? what makes that person any different from a pub? other than a clan +1?
We know, BN has somewhat higher standards, and CHAO cant just jump in and copy that, because BN has the larger "solid" playerbase; while chao has a "migrational" playerbase. Players who come and go, but generally, the clan stays active; which is good for the clan.
What chao is doing, works for chao; what BN is doing, is working for BN. Would be silly for either clan to change their styles, especially TOWARDS the other style; then we would be recruiting from eachothers player type.